James Carroll Carroll من عند Hoscheid, لوكسمبورغ من عند Hoscheid, لوكسمبورغ

This was a beautiful, brilliant book. I loved the naivete of Bobby, and the way he develops in his relationship with Clare and Jonathan. The movie, far from being trite, was equally as beautiful as the book.

I really enjoy these books. A solid 4 1/2 stars from me. This is the 7th one in the series. I've always liked the books but this one kept me riveted. I don't know if they are getting better or if I am just so comfortable with the characters now that it is like being with family. I wish I could be as smart as Maisie --the mysteries that she solves always keep me guessing until the very end.